“Good Job!” Isn’t Building the Confidence You Think.
You want confident kids, so you do the thing that feels like it builds confidence: you praise. “Good job.” “You’re so smart.” “Amazing.” A hundred times a day, warmly, because you mean it and because you want them to believe in themselves.
It seems like it should work. More praise, more confidence.
But here’s the uncomfortable finding: the wrong kind of praise doesn’t build confidence. Sometimes it quietly does the opposite.
Does praising my child actually build their confidence?
It depends entirely on what you praise. The Child Mind Institute draws the line between praising the outcome and praising the effort. Their guidance is blunt about the exact phrase in this post’s title: instead of “Good job!”, say what the good job was — “Good job sharing your toys with your brother.” Be specific, and you point a child at what they did rather than what they are. As they put it, praising effort is not the same as praising success: telling a child they’re smart doesn’t teach them which part was smart. And the companion lesson is that failure has to stay survivable — Dr. Harold Koplewicz, the Institute’s founding president, warns that if you praise success, kids learn failure is bad, when it’s simply one of the possible outcomes.
So the boldest-looking confidence isn’t the kind that needs a “good job” to stay up. It’s the kind a child builds by trying, struggling, and finding out they can handle the wobble. Your words can point them toward that — or quietly teach them to fear the drop.
What actually helps
Praise the effort and the strategy, not the person. “You figured out a different way to do that” beats “you’re so smart” every time.
Let them do hard things. Competence — real, earned — builds confidence that a compliment can’t. Resist rescuing too fast.
Let them wobble. A kid who learns that getting it wrong is survivable grows steadier than a kid who’s only ever been told they’re great.
Where the Krewelings come in
Taz the tiger is bold and proud — but the real Taz-confidence is the kind that survives a stumble and gets back up grinning. Naming a child’s effort (“that was a real Taz try — you stuck with it”) teaches the truth underneath: confidence isn’t handed to you in a “good job.” It’s built, one hard thing at a time.
Keep the warmth — kids need to feel seen. Just aim it at the trying, not the trophy. The confidence that lasts is the kind a child built themselves, and got to feel you notice.
Should I stop praising my child?
No — just shift what you praise. Move from person-praise (“you’re so smart / so talented”) to effort- and strategy-praise (“you worked hard on that,” “you tried a new way”), and be specific rather than a blanket “good job.” The warmth stays; the target changes. That shift protects kids from becoming approval-dependent or afraid to fail, and it points them toward the mastery that actually builds durable confidence. Praise a reasonable effort honestly — kids can tell when it’s inflated.
It’s okay to feel what you feel — even when what you feel is I did that MYSELF.
Read next: They Know the Answer. They Just Can’t Say It Out Loud. — confidence for the quiet kids. And to find your student’s feeling friend, take the quiz.
Pin this for later
